Live account survival
Propfy keeps daily loss room and trailing drawdown room per account in front of you, so the review is about the account you still have.
Early bird: 30% OFF all plans · ends Oct 27
EARLY30
Prop-firm journal comparison
Propfy vs Edgewonk: measured discipline against structured reflection.
Edgewonk is a psychology-led journal built on deliberate manual self-review. Propfy is built for prop firm futures operations: per-account drawdown, rule adherence, copied-trade decisions, and a review that protects the account you are trading today.
Discipline, measured
Rule adherence, size drift, and time-to-re-entry are computed from synced trades instead of relying on manual tagging alone.
Decision-true counts
One signal copied across accounts is one behavioral decision. Money, fees, and slippage stay real on every account.
Where Edgewonk is strong
A deliberate, psychology-led review process with custom statistics and tilt analysis that rewards traders who invest in manual reflection.
Focused prop-firm workflow
TopstepX sync and CSV import with evaluation, Express, and later account phases treated as first-class context.
Review that ends in an action
Each session review is designed to produce one concrete correction, short enough to repeat daily.
Direct comparison
Propfy or Edgewonk: which is better?
Choose Propfy when live prop-account risk — daily loss room, trailing drawdown, multiple mirrored accounts — needs to sit at the center of the review. Choose Edgewonk when a structured, psychology-first manual journaling process is the priority and live account operations matter less. Neither is automatically better for every trader.
| Comparison point | Propfy | Edgewonk |
|---|---|---|
| Primary focus | Prop-firm futures operations | Psychology-led journaling and structured self-review |
| Copied trades | Groups mirrored fills as one behavioral decision while retaining every account result | Confirm how a copier workflow fits its import and tagging model |
| Account risk | Tracks each account against its own daily and trailing limits and surfaces the most constrained account | General journal statistics; prop-rule context is the trader’s to maintain |
| Psychology | Discipline metrics computed from trade data: size drift, re-entry timing, rule streaks | Deep manual reflection: tilt tracking, custom statistics, structured review |
| Platform coverage | TopstepX auto-sync and CSV import, with a deliberately focused scope | Import-based workflow across asset classes; verify current broker support |
| Best fit | Prop firm futures traders focused on account survival and discipline | Traders who want a deliberate, reflection-heavy journaling process |
| Trial | 7-day free trial, no credit card required (30% early-bird discount on paid plans) | Check Edgewonk for its current trial and pricing terms |
A fair comparison, kept current
Both products evolve. This page describes the workflows each is designed around, not a feature-by-feature audit frozen in time — verify current capabilities and pricing on both sites before choosing.
Frequently asked questions
Is Propfy an Edgewonk alternative?
Yes for prop firm futures traders who need live per-account risk, prop-firm phases, and copied fills grouped into decisions. Edgewonk remains a strong choice for traders who want a deliberate, psychology-led journaling process built on structured self-review.
Is Edgewonk good for prop-firm trading?
Edgewonk’s structured review process applies to any trading, including prop accounts. What it does not center on is prop-specific operations — daily loss room, trailing drawdown against a firm limit, and multiple mirrored accounts — which is the workflow Propfy is built around. Verify current Edgewonk features directly, as products change.
Which journal is better for trading psychology?
They approach it differently. Edgewonk leads with structured self-analysis: tilt tracking, custom statistics, and disciplined manual review. Propfy measures the behaviors that end prop firm accounts — size drift, revenge-entry timing, rule adherence — from synced trade data. Traders who want deep manual reflection may prefer Edgewonk; traders who want discipline measured automatically may prefer Propfy.
How can traders try Propfy?
The approved launch offer is a 7-day free trial with no credit card required, plus a 30% early-bird discount on the paid plans — a discount, not a longer trial. Current plan details are published on the Propfy pricing page.
Build the process that keeps accounts alive.
Try the complete journal for 7 days with no credit card. Connect your trading data when you are ready.
Start 7-day free trial